The winds of (hopefully) change are sweeping through the fighting game community (FGC). Due to a number of repeated incidents of flagrant pot splitting and collusion in grand finals, a coalition of tournament organisers and related websites has got together to stamp out the process.
Here is the new rule being adopted care of Eventhubs:
Competitive spirit is the lifeblood of the fighting game community. Unfortunately, this year we have seen a few incidents where players intentionally underperformed, usually in the final matches of a tournament. This behavior is unacceptable, and it must end.
To guarantee the integrity of future tournaments, major tournament directors have come together to standardize Evo’s rule regarding player collusion:
“Collusion of any kind with your competitors is considered cheating. If the Tournament Director determines that any competitor is colluding to manipulate the results or intentionally underperforming, the collaborating players may be immediately disqualified. This determination is to be made at the sole discretion of the Tournament Director. Anyone disqualified in this manner forfeits all rights to any titles or prizes they might have otherwise earned for that tournament.”
Since that time a lot of people have commented on if this has been a good idea or not. The consensus from most is that it is a great initiative and that something had to be done. On the other hand, there is some concern about sites like SRK or Eventhubs not covering events that do not agree to this rule. Either way, it seems that doing something is better than nothing so we will all cross that bridge if problems arise from it down the track.
The top players to whom this change has been directed? Well they have often taken the opposite approach. Without calling out individuals, a clear pattern of comments along the lines of “we should be able to pick who we want” or “it is unfair, why should tournaments have this power” makes it clear that they don’t understand the real issue at all.
This drama all culminated in the SF4 grand finals at the Next Level Battle Circuit weekly event (NLBC) when we were about to be subjected to an unusual Yang/Balrog grand final. Quite rightly the broadcaster Spooky pulled the plug on this contemptuous display. Given the recent events it was almost unthinkable that the players involved wouldn’t have just picked their best and played it out. But instead here we are and it seems the real issue still hasn’t sunk in.
So this is where I will try to lay it out from a different perspective. I’m not from New York or California. In fact I’m on the other side of the world and will likely never get to go to a major American tournament. Nor, due to work and distance (this is a big ass country) am I involved in the major scenes in Australia, where groups like the Shadowloo do amazing work without any of the drama that gets associated with the FGC. Does that make my opinion of fighting games irrelevant? Maybe. So I’m not going to talk about frame traps or the validity of counter picking. Instead, I’m going to talk about life and here is a real beauty to throw at you:
If you don’t have a career and the start of a family by the time you are about twenty five? You are just fucking around.
That’ll be a statement that gets a lot of people offside, especially those younger or around that mark who haven’t achieved those seemingly arbitrary milestones. Even lots of people in their thirties or older will be scoffing at that and arguing that they are just doing fine and dandy as they are.
That might be true, you probably are doing fine. The point is that for most people? If you are not working towards those goals you are going to reach a point one day when you had wished that you had. You don’t need kids at 25. But when you have them at 35 your perspective on life will change. I know, I’m old enough to look back and think about what might have been. I can see missed opportunities, I regret time wasted on certain things and not enough time spent on others. I wish I had a better house and a faster car. And you know what? I’m actually not doing too badly at all.
How does this relate to collusion and the FGC? Well the link is quite clear to my mind from the two different parties involved.
Firstly organisers. Don’t believe the rumours and hype, these people are dedicating large portions of their lives to a mostly thankless and unprofitable task. What do they get in return? The satisfaction of a job well done, some experience and something they can look back on when they are older and feel proud about. When players do not take these events seriously? They are robbing these people of that feeling. Through no fault of their own, they are dragging these people down to the status of just fucking around.
Tournaments do not have to exist, streams do not have to be set up and nursed through hours and hours of free entertainment. Instead of spending a hundred hours on an event? These same people could spend a hundred hours interning for free at an event organisation company. It isn’t enough to just do something for the love of it. One day you’ll have somebody looking at you across the dinner table asking why they can’t go on a holiday this year. The answer may be that you spent six months running “Fighter Event 7” instead of building towards a promotion. When that talk happens? You will not want your kid watching the grand final on Youtube and seeing Dan vs Juri as the crowd boos. You’ll want to show them something that mattered, to you, because you loved it and so did everybody else that was there.
If you can, they’ll understand (eventually).
For players themselves it is even worse. The line that often gets thrown around is “I play for fun”. This sounds like a lie, to yourself and others or at least a short sighted mistake. Playing for fun is working a 50 hour week to feed your family and getting your mates around on the weekend for some beers and marvel. Fun is going to a tournament, finding another player and throwing down for $20 in a hastily cobbled together money match. Fun is never getting to a grand final and not trying your best and not taking it seriously because you feel you have nothing to gain by winning. If it is fun for you? Realise that it is only fun because it is a competitive tournament you got through, exactly the thing you are actively working to destroy. Players will walk away, sponsors will abandon you and organisers will start talking to the Dota crowd. Then you are left just holding your stick with a lot of wasted hours behind you. When you are flipping burgers or trying to learn how to play League of Legends properly? You’ll wish you had been working towards a degree instead.
Trust me, that feeling of regret is not going to be fun.
There are really two choices you have. Get a real job, get a real family and really play for fun. If you do this? You’ll enjoy your games, get the things you’ll one day wish you had got earlier and you’ll never have that awkward moment where you wake up and realise you have pissed away thousands of hours of your life.
The alternative is to play to win. Train like a crazy man, show up to every tournament and always present your best and body anybody who dares to sit down beside you. One day you still might wake up with no money living in a bad neighbourhood alone in your bed. But you know what? You’ll at least be able to look back at your time and know that you gave it your all. The FGC might have taken off or it might not have. But you would have tried your best to help every tournament organiser and every sponsor and every tournament to be the best it can be.
And you can be proud of that. And that’ll be enough.
So my plea to the “top players” who don’t understand what this is all about is for them to stop and really think it over. What are you going to be? Somebody who is pushing the FGC to be the best it can be? Somebody who is just playing games for fun and getting on with their real lives? Or somebody who is just fucking around and heading for a really bad epiphany at some point down the track.
You can’t have it all and at some point you have to choose. Next time you sit down at a grand final no matter how small the pot? Pick your best, win the match and smile to the camera after. You never know, things might just start to work out for you.